On Tap

We offer a rotating selection of craft beers brewed in house by Jake Nelson. You’re welcome to order growlers or cans to go.

Little Wing

16 oz. pint ~ 6; 64 oz. growler ~ 16

Our award-winning American Pilsner ~ 5.2% ABV

Wasserwolf Jäger

0.5 L mug ~ 7; 1.0 L mug ~ 12

Munich-style Dunkel Lager brewed yearly to celebrate the Oktoberfest season. Munich malts contribute a rich, bready character that is balanced by the German noble hops. Our house lager yeast keeps it crisp and drinkable. ~ 5.3% ABV

Boogie Chillen'

16 oz pint ~ 7; 64 oz growler ~ 20

American Pale Ale with grapefruit and Citra & Mosaic Hops ~ 5.5% ABV

Kitchen Sink

16 oz pint ~ 6; 64 oz growler ~ 18

Pale Ale with American and European hops. ~ 5.6% ABV

Balin' Straw

16 oz pint ~ 7; 64 oz growler ~ 21

Belgian-style Saison. Dry, floral, and hoppy with notes of white wine, gooseberry, and lychee from a healthy dose of New Zealand Nelson Sauvin Hops. 6.1% ABV

Cheval Deux

12 oz snifter ~7; 64 oz growler ~ 28

Bier De Garde (a French farmhouse style), brewed with sweet potatoes, vanilla beans, and spices. A warming dark amber colored beer, Cheval is perfect for the cold weather months. ~ 6.% ABV

Mojo Working

14 oz teku/tulip ~ 7; 64 oz growler ~ 23

This hazy magenta colored sour ale is bursting with jammy dark fruit flavors from hefty additions of raspberry, blackberry, and sweet cherry purées. Sweet fruits balance the moderate acidity of the kettle sour ale and make for an incredibly drinkable beer that doesn’t easily overwhelm the taste buds. 6.4% ABV

Front Flips (2022)

14 oz tulip ~ 8; 64 oz growler ~ 28

American Farmhouse Ale brewed with a blend of saison and brett strains and aged for 11 months in our resident french oak barrels. Lemon, tangerine, black pepper, and hay funk notes lead to a dry and refreshing finish with just a slight acidity. 6.9% ABV


16 oz. pint ~ 7; 64 oz. growler ~ 22

Double Dry Hopped Hazy IPA with Mosaic and Citra Hops ~ 6.5% ABV


16oz pint ~ 7; 64oz growler ~ 18

West-coast IPA featuring loads of piney and citrusy hop notes with an aggressive bitterness. ~ 7.2% ABV

Delta Hurricane

12 oz snifter ~ 6; 64 oz growler ~ 22

Inspired by the New Orleans Coffee blend, our imperial milk stout uses a blend of chicory and single-origin Honduras coffee beans roasted locally by 4 Letter Word Coffee. 8% ABV

Life By The Drop

12 oz snifter ~ 9; 750 ml bottle ~20; no growlers

Life By The Drop is a Belgian-style Quadrupel Ale aged in Journeyman Rye Whiskey barrels. Dark brown, rich, and full of depth, this beer is a flavor powerhouse. Look for notes of raisins, dates, plums, brown sugar, and honey, thanks to the fruity Belgian yeast. ~ 11% ABV

Mixed Drinks

Hand crafted artisanal cocktails are a specialty at Horse Thief Hollow. We source from local distilleries when possible and incorporate our own house made spirits and syrups infused with herbs, fruit, vegetables, and spices.


Neil's Barrel-Aged Old Fashioned


Handcrafted with a blend of bourbons including Elijah Craig, along with Demerara sugar & Luxardo cherry juice, and served with a garnish of cherry & orange peel. Neil aged it in an 18th Street Distillery bourbon barrel, to impart richer flavors & aromas as the elements mingle. It’s our unique way of elevating Chicago’s favorite cocktail.

Strawberry Fields Four-Ever


Strawberry & rhubarb with fresh squeezed lemon & Four Roses bourbon.

The Golden Ticket


Aloo Vodka, Buffalo Creme, chocolate syrup and Aztec Bitters

Gettin' Figgy With It


Figs were made for fall, and this Manhattan features Journeyman Field Rye infused with Black Mission figs, Starlino sweet vermouth, honey bitters, and cherry juice. Award-winning Field Rye celebrates Chicago history and the 125th anniversary of the iconic Field Museum. We’ll drink to that!

Dizzy Lizzy


Don Q white rum, Falernum, Gran Gala, fresh squeezed lime and orange juice, splash of cranberry juice

Back to Blackberry


Aloo Vodka, Blackberry Liqueur, fresh squeezed lime juice topped with ginger beer and mint leaves

Tequila Mockingbird


Blanco Tequila, jalapeno liqueur, blood orange liqueur, fresh squeezed lime juice and Tajin rim

Purple Haze


Bar Hill Gin, Butterfly Pea tea infused simple syrup, fresh lemon and Tiki Bitters served Straight up.

Cider & Canned Drinks

Original Sin Black Widow Cider - 12 oz. can


Blackberries and freshly pressed New York apples create a cider that is fruit-forward, tart and complex.

Original Sin Hard Cider - 12 oz. can


A dry traditional cider, fermented with two types of Champagne yeast and made with freshly pressed New York apples.


Fleur Pinot Noir

10 glass / 36 bottle

Napa Valley, California. Flavors of freshly picked raspberries and strawberries explode across the palate with subtle hints of peppery spice and tea. The mouthfeel is supple, rich, and elegant.

Broadside Cabernet Sauvignon

10 glass / 36 bottle

Paso Robles, California. Offers aromas of ripe strawberry and red cherry framed by a touch of oak. Supple and open-knit on the palate, with a juicy core of fruit and light structuring tannins, and a long finish.

Sea Enchantress Red Blend

9 glass / 30 bottle

Sedona, California. The 2019 blend consists of our Petite Sirah, Old Vine Zinfandel, Tempranillo and Syrah which is rich and full of flavors of ripe blackberries, fresh dark plums, bing cherries and blueberries.

Oak Grove Reserve Merlot

10 glass / 36 bottle

California. A favorite that marries rich, complex flavors of blackberries and plum with a touch of black pepper while supple tannins give way to a long, smooth, finish.

Tomero Malbec

10 glass / 36 bottle

Uco Valley, Argentina. Intense red with violet colors. Notes of red currants, cherries and cinnamon.

Dry Creek Heritage Vines Zinfandel

11 glass / 37 bottle

Dry Creek Valley, California. This vintage presents enticing aromatics of dried cranberry and boysenberry with hints of cocoa powder, nutmeg, dried sage, and cedar.

Dry Creek The Mariner

55 Bottle Only

Dry Creek Valley, California. Bordeaux-inspired blend of the most prized variations at Dry Creek. 69% Cabernet Sauvignon, 15% Merlot, 6% Cabernet Franc, 5% Malbec, 5% Petit Verdot

Dry Creek Fume Blanc

Bottle Only ~ 40

Dry Creek offers stainless steel fermented, no oak style Fumé Blanc is crisp, balanced and immediately drinkable. Winery founder David Stare was the first vintner to plant Sauvignon Blanc in the Dry Creek Valley, and we are proud to carry his legacy forward in producing this classic, dry, refreshing white wine.

Dry Creek Sauvignon Blanc

9 glass / 32 bottle

Dry Creek Valley, California. Aromas of pineapple and ripe pear with some floral notes. Flavors of Meyer lemons, tangerines and mineral notes come through, with a lively and slightly creamy finish.

Valley of the Moon Chardonnay

10 glass / 36 bottle

Sonoma, California. Hints of caramelized oak and vanilla flavors make for a well-rounded Chardonnay with great balance and lingering viscosity. A glass full of lemon shortbread to the nose, sips like lemon cream pie with a light touch of cinnamon and nutmeg.

Stefano Christiani Pinot Grigio

10 glass / 35 bottle

Salorno, Italy. Aroma rich in fruit, with striking notes of pear and apple. Dry and smooth on the palate with a pleasant, mineral aftertaste.

La Bella Prosecco

9 glass / 32 bottle

Veneto, Italy. Dry, sparkling, white wine that is intensely aromatic and complex, as well as fragrant and fruity with flavors of apples and pears.

Le Val Rosé

9 glass / 32 bottle

France. Fresh and deliciously fruity wine with a soft side. Resplendent with ripe berry flavors and warm acidity, along with a lively, sunny character.

Maryhill Riesling

10 glass / 36 bottle

Colombia Valley, Washington. Lively citrus flavors frame the palate with honey and pear, with lemongrass aromas complemented by lilac.


We hand select the finest craft spirits. Taste them for yourself.


Journeyman’s Field Vodka

Three Oaks, Michigan

Prairie Organic Cucumber

Princeton, Minnesota


Frankfort, Kentucky

Gin & Aquavit

Aloo Gin


Journeyman's Field Gin

Three Oaks, Michigan

Koval Cranberry Gin

Chicago, Illinois

Ungava Barrel Aged Gin



Don Q Cristal

Ponce, Puerto Rico

Koloa Kaua’i Spiced

Kalaheo, Kaua’i, Hawaii

Plantation Aged


Tequila & Mezcal

Campo Azul Blanco

Jalisco, Mexico

Campo Azul Resposado

Jesus Maria, Jalisco

Amaras Espadin Mezcal

Oaxaca, Mexico

Banhez Espadin Mezcal

Oaxaca, Mexico

Scotch & Cognac

Glenfiddich Gran Cru

Banffshire, Scotland

Lagavulin 16 Year

Lagavulin, Islay, Scotland

Monkey Shoulder Scotch

Dufftown, Banffshire, Scotland

Cognac Park VS


Brandy & Liqueur

Dry Sack Medium Sherry

Cadiz, Andalusia, Spain

Gran Gala Orange Liqueur

Triestes, Italy

Barrow's Ginger Liqueur

Brooklyn, New York


Chicago, Illinois

Millard Fillmore Brandy

Ukiah, California

St. George's Absinthe

Alameda, California

Bourbon, Rye & Irish Whiskey

1792 Full Proof

Bardstown, Kentucky

Blanton's Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Buffalo Trace Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Clyde Mays Cask Strength

Auburndale, Florida

Eagle Rare Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Elmer T. Lee Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Few Bourbon

Evanston, Illinois

Furthur Straight Rye


George T. Stagg Jr.

Frankfort, Kentucky

Glendolough Irish

Glendolough, Ireland

Hancock Reserve

Frankfort, Kentucky

High West Campfire

High West, Utah

John J. Bowman Bourbon

Fredericksburg, Virginia

John J. Bowman Port Cask

Fredericksburg, Virginia

Journeyman's Corsets, Whips, and Whiskey

Three Oaks, Michigan

Journeyman's Last Feather Rye

Three Oaks, Michigan

Journeyman's Silver Cross Whiskey

Three Oaks, Michigan

Koval Bourbon

Chicago, Illinois

Paddy's Irish Whiskey

Cork, Ireland

Rossville Union Rye

Lawrenceburg, Indiana

Tom’s Foolery Bonded Rye

Chagrin Falls, Ohio

Sazerac Rye

Frankfort, Kentucky

Weller Antique 107

Frankfort, Kentucky

Weller Special Reserve

Frankfort, Kentucky

West Cork Bourbon Cask

West Cork, Ireland

Whistle Pig Rye

Middlebury, Vermont

Willet Pot Still

Bardstown, Kentucky

Four Roses