On Tap

We offer a rotating selection of craft beers brewed in house by Jake Nelson. You’re welcome to order growlers or cans to go.

Space Face

16oz pint ~ 6; 4-pack 16oz can ~ 14; 64oz growler ~ 18

Kolsch-style ale, inspired by the classic German style but fermented with a Norwegian farmhouse yeast for a new take on the style. Light notes of citrus, pear, and spice on top of an easy drinking and refreshing beer. ~ 4.6% ABV

Little Wing

16oz pint ~ 6; 4-pack 16oz can ~ 10; 64oz growler ~ 16

Our award-wining American Pilsner ~ 5.2% ABV

Pink Pom Pom

16oz pint ~ 7; 64oz growler ~ 20

Hefeweizen with pomegranate and cherry juice added ~ 5.1% ABV


16oz pint ~ 6; 4-pack 16oz cans ~ 14; 64oz growler ~ 16

German-style Hefeweizen ~ 5.5% ABV

Because Of The Brave

16oz pint ~7; 64oz growler ~ 22

Brewed for PTSD Awareness Month in June, Because of the Brave benefits the Road Home Program at Rush, which provides mental health and wellness care to veterans and their families. In collaboration with our friends at Open Outcry Brewing, we got together and came up with a new hazy pale ale recipe. Each brewery brewed the same base beer and we both chose a different single hop variety for our respective takes. Because Of The Brave features El Dorado hops lending notes of pineapple, pear, watermelon, and peach to a medium bodied and refreshing beer with a slightly sweet finish. ~ 5.3% ABV


16oz pint ~ 6; 64oz growler ~ 18

Hoppy American Wheat Ale with Amarillo and Calypso hops. Full-bodied with a firm bitterness, 3030 features notes of grapefruit, melon, peach, and orange peel. ~ 6.2% ABV


16oz pint ~ 7; 4-pack 16oz can ~ 16; 64oz growler ~ 24

Double dry-hopped Hazy IPA ~ 6.5% ABV


16oz pint ~ $7; 64oz growler $18

West-Coast IPA with loads of pine and citrus notes ~ 7.2% ABV

The Colonel

12oz snifter ~ 8

Bourbon barrel-aged wheatwine with ginger and lemon peel, aged 12 months ~ 11% ABV

Mixed Drinks

Hand crafted artisanal cocktails are a specialty at Horse Thief Hollow. We source from local distilleries when possible and incorporate our own house made spirits and syrups infused with herbs, fruit, vegetables, and spices.

Dine In Cocktails

Aloe From the Other Side


Tequila blanco, Barsol pisco, aloe liqueur, fresh grapefruit & lime juices create a refreshing Paloma.

An Old-Fashioned Cola


Journeyman’s Silver Cross Whiskey and a Classic Coca-Cola reduced syrup with a twist of lime craft an Old Fashioned for warm weather.

Voodoo Chile


Tequila blanco, Green Chartreuse liqueur, passionfruit, fresh lime & splash of absinthe give this fruity, herbal cocktail a French twist.

Mint to Do That


Prairie Organic Cucumber vodka, Jokigen Yuzu sake, fresh lemon & mint make a refreshing summer drink that tastes like sunshine..

Once and Floral


Apologue’s Aronia Liqueur shines through with gin and fresh lemon juice to provide a “berry” tasty gin cocktail.

Jolene's Here!


Tequila reposado, Gran Gala, Cilantro liqueur, fresh strawberries, lime juice, a splash of “Hefewestern” & a mist of mezcal yield an original Margarita to welcome the newest member of our HTH family, Stacey’s baby Jolene!



Backwoods bourbon, Aloo Gin, bergamot liqueur, lime, bitters, & ginger beer create a classic Tiki cocktail.

Big Gulps, Huh?

Serves 2 - $30

White Sangria with Mary Hill Riesling, Prairie Organic vodka, Gran Gala, and fresh fruit create a fun sangria with rotating flavors. Ask you server and enjoy a cocktail for two!

Cider & Canned Drinks

Seattle Cider - Basil Mint - 16 oz. can


Seattle, Washington. Fermented with fresh basil and mint, this off-dry cider starts savory and floral, complemented perfectly by a tart, clean finish.

Seattle Cider - Dry Cider - 16 oz. can


Seattle, Washington. Dry and pleasantly acidic, flavors of nectarine, under ripe peach and tart cherry hit the palate with no residual sweetness.

Skin Contact Piquette - Natural Wine Spritzer - 12 oz. can


Westminster, Maryland. Spritzy and refreshing orange piquette with flavors of grapefruit juice and peel, pink starburst, white sage.

Ranch Water - Grapefruit Blue Agave Hard Seltzer - 12 oz. can


Hard Seltzer from Texas

Ranch Water - Lime Blue Agave Hard Seltzer - 12 oz. can


Hard Seltzer from Texas


Fleur Pinot Noir

10 glass / 36 bottle

Napa Valley, California. Flavors of freshly picked raspberries and strawberries explode across the palate with subtle hints of peppery spice and tea. The mouthfeel is supple, rich, and elegant.

Dry Creek The Mariner

55 Bottle Only

Dry Creek Valley, California. Bordeaux-inspired blend of the most prized variations at Dry Creek. 69% Cabernet Sauvignon, 15% Merlot, 6% Cabernet Franc, 5% Malbec, 5% Petit Verdot

Trentadue Old Patch Red

9 glass / 30 bottle

Sedona, California. Nuances of ripe plums, vanilla, and cocoa are showing with a slight dose of oak and toast.

Dry Creek Heritage Vines Zinfandel

11 glass / 37 bottle

Dry Creek Valley, California. This vintage presents enticing aromatics of dried cranberry and boysenberry with hints of cocoa powder, nutmeg, dried sage, and cedar.

Oak Grove Reserve Merlot

10 glass / 36 bottle

California. A favorite that marries rich, complex flavors of blackberries and plum with a touch of black pepper while supple tannins give way to a long, smooth, finish.

Tomero Malbec

10 glass / 36 bottle

Uco Valley, Argentina. Intense red with violet colors. Notes of red currants, cherries and cinnamon.

Broadside Cabernet Sauvignon

10 glass / 36 bottle

Paso Robles, California. Offers aromas of ripe strawberry and red cherry framed by a touch of oak. Supple and open-knit on the palate, with a juicy core of fruit and light structuring tannins, and a long finish.

Maryhill Riesling

10 glass / 36 bottle

Colombia Valley, Washington. Lively citrus flavors frame the palate with honey and pear, with lemongrass aromas complemented by lilac.

Dry Creek Fume Blanc

Bottle Only ~ 40

Dry Creek offers stainless steel fermented, no oak style Fumé Blanc is crisp, balanced and immediately drinkable. Winery founder David Stare was the first vintner to plant Sauvignon Blanc in the Dry Creek Valley, and we are proud to carry his legacy forward in producing this classic, dry, refreshing white wine.

La Bella Prosecco

9 glass / 32 bottle

Veneto, Italy. Dry, sparkling, white wine that is intensely aromatic and complex, as well as fragrant and fruity with flavors of apples and pears.

Stefano Christiani Pinot Grigio

10 glass / 35 bottle

Salorno, Italy. Aroma rich in fruit, with striking notes of pear and apple. Dry and smooth on the palate with a pleasant, mineral aftertaste.

Le Val Rosé

9 glass / 32 bottle

France. Fresh and deliciously fruity wine with a soft side. Resplendent with ripe berry flavors and warm acidity, along with a lively, sunny character.

Dry Creek Sauvignon Blanc

9 glass / 32 bottle

Dry Creek Valley, California. Aromas of pineapple and ripe pear with some floral notes. Flavors of Meyer lemons, tangerines and mineral notes come through, with a lively and slightly creamy finish.

Valley of the Moon Chardonnay

10 glass / 36 bottle

Sonoma, California. Hints of caramelized oak and vanilla flavors make for a well-rounded Chardonnay with great balance and lingering viscosity. A glass full of lemon shortbread to the nose, sips like lemon cream pie with a light touch of cinnamon and nutmeg.


We hand select the finest craft spirits. Taste them for yourself.


Journeyman’s Field Vodka

Three Oaks, Michigan

Prairie Organic

Princeton, Minnesota

Prairie Organic Cucumber

Princeton, Minnesota


Frankfort, Kentucky

Gin & Aquavit

Aloo Gin


Journeyman's Field Gin

Three Oaks, Michigan

Koval Cranberry Gin

Chicago, Illinois

Ungava Barrel Aged Gin



Don Q Cristal

Ponce, Puerto Rico

Koloa Kaua’i Spiced

Kalaheo, Kaua’i, Hawaii

Plantation Aged


Tequila & Mezcal

Cimmaron Blanco

Jalisco, Mexico

Campo Azul Resposado

Jesus Maria, Jalisco

Cruz de Fuego Espadin Mezcal

Oaxaca, Mexico

Mezcal Amaras Espadin

Oaxaca, Mexico

Scotch & Cognac

Glenfiddich Gran Cru

Banffshire, Scotland

Lagavulin 16 Year

Lagavulin, Islay, Scotland

Monkey Shoulder Scotch

Dufftown, Banffshire, Scotland

Cognac Park VS


Brandy & Liqueur

Dry Sack Medium Sherry

Cadiz, Andalusia, Spain

Gran Gala Orange Liqueur

Triestes, Italy

Kringle Cream Liqueur

Middleton, Wisconsin

Barrow's Ginger Liqueur

Brooklyn, New York


Chicago, Illinois

Millard Fillmore Brandy

Ukiah, California

St. George's Absinthe

Alameda, California

Bourbon, Rye & Irish Whiskey

1792 Full Proof

Bardstown, Kentucky

Blackened Bourbon

Shoreham, Vermont

Blanton's Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Breckenridge Bourbon

Breckenridge, Colorado

Buffalo Trace Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Clyde Mays Cask Strength

Auburndale, Florida

Eagle Rare Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Few Bourbon

Evanston, Illinois

Furthur Straight Rye


George T. Stagg Jr.

Frankfort, Kentucky

Glendolough Irish

Glendolough, Ireland

Hancock Reserve

Frankfort, Kentucky

High West Campfire

High West, Utah

John J. Bowman Bourbon

Fredericksburg, Virginia

John J. Bowman Port Cask

Fredericksburg, Virginia

Journeyman's Corsets, Whips, and Whiskey

Three Oaks, Michigan

Journeyman's Last Feather Rye

Three Oaks, Michigan

Journeyman's Silver Cross Whiskey

Three Oaks, Michigan

Koval Bourbon

Chicago, Illinois

Koval Millet

Chicago, Illinois

Old Pogue Master’s Select 12 Year

Maysville, Kentucky

Paddy's Irish Whiskey

Cork, Ireland

Rossville Union Rye

Lawrenceburg, Indiana

Tom’s Foolery Bonded Rye

Chagrin Falls, Ohio

Sazerac Rye

Frankfort, Kentucky

Weller Antique 107

Frankfort, Kentucky

Weller Special Reserve

Frankfort, Kentucky

West Cork Bourbon Cask

West Cork, Ireland

Whistle Pig Rye

Middlebury, Vermont

Willet Pot Still

Bardstown, Kentucky