Ready for Lent

Enjoy a variety of meat-free options on our menu

Our popular Lake Perch with Fries dinner is back at Horse Thief Hollow for the Lenten season. Enjoy it every Friday till Easter. We have plenty of other choices for those avoiding meat. Try any of our freshly prepared salads or our Veggie Burger, Lt. Dan Shrimp Sandwich, and Vegan Mushroom French Dip!

We’re Open!

Tuesday through Sunday, 12 to 11 pm

We’re pleased to officially reopen for indoor dining while following COVID protocols for the safety of our team and loyal customers. You are also welcome to order food, beer, and batch cocktails from our carryout menu.

Feathers in our cap

Horse Thief Hollow captures medals in prestigious beer competitions

We brew great beer and have the bling to prove it. In 2020, our Little Wing Pilsner snagged a Bronze Medal in the Great American Beer Festival. And Wrenly Rose won Gold at the Festival of Wood & Barrel-Aged Beer. We also brought home the Gold in the 2018 World Beer Cup and a Silver Medal in the 2017 Great American Beer Festival for our French farmhouse ale Bière de Voleur, or Thief’s Beer. In 2016, we earned Bronze in the Great American Beer Festival for our Prunckle’s Dunkel, a dark German lager with nutty malted sweetness. We also snagged first place in the 2016 Festival of Barrel Aged Beers for a Bavarian wheat beer called Hilltop Weizenbock. The 2014 World Beer Cup awarded us a Silver Medal for our Cheval Deux, a fall seasonal French brown ale infused with sweet potato. And we earned a Bronze for our signature 18th Rebellion Kolsch Ale, a Zwickelbier, at the 2014 GABF.

Jake and Neil celebrate winning a gold medal for Wrenly Rose at the 2020 Festival of Wood and Barrel-Aged Beer

On Tap

We offer a rotating selection of craft beers brewed in house by Jake Nelson. You’re welcome to order growlers or cans to go.

Little Wing

16oz pint ~ 6; 64oz growler ~ 16; 4-pack 16oz cans ~ 10

American Pilsner brewed with 100% malted barley ~ 5.2% ABV

Wasserwolf Jäger

16oz pint ~ 6; 64oz growler ~ 18; 4-pack 16oz cans ~ 12

Munich-style Dunkel. This lager features bready, toasty, and a slightly chocolatey malt character while also being smooth and refreshing ~ 5.3% ABV

Pat Mac's

16oz pint~ 7; 4-pack 16oz cans ~ 14; 64oz growler ~ 16

Irish Red Ale brewed yearly in conjunction with Pat Mac's Pack, a local organization that supports Pediatric Brain Tumor Research. A portion of the can sales directly benefits Pat Mac's Pack. ~ 5.0% ABV

Disco Infiltrator

To-go only: 4-pack 16oz cans ~ 16

Hazy Pale Ale featuring Citra & Sabro Hops ~ 5.9% ABV


16oz pint can ~ 7; 4-pack 16oz cans ~ 16; 64oz growler ~ 24

Double dry-hopped Hazy IPA ~ 6.5% ABV


16oz pint ~ 7; 64oz growler ~16

West Coast IPA ~ 7.2% ABV

Cheval Deux

12oz snifter ~7; 64oz growler ~ 26

Bier De Garde (a French farmhouse style), brewed with sweet potatoes, vanilla beans, and spices. A warming dark amber colored beer, Cheval is perfect for the cold weather months ~ 5.8% ABV

Ninja Sloth

12 oz snifter ~ 6; 64 oz growler ~ 22

Stout with chocolate, caramel, pecans, and lactose. Brewed in collaboration with Sweet Freaks Chocolates! ~ 6.6% ABV

Delta Hurricane

16oz pint ~ 7; 64oz growler ~ 22

Milk stout with chicory and coffee. Inspired by the New Orleans coffee blend ~ 6.9% ABV

Wrenly Rose

12oz snifter ~ 8; 64oz growler ~32

Belgian-style Tripel brewed with French Pilsen malt & American hops, fermented with a classic Belgian Trappist yeast, then aged 8 months in Wren Hop Pinot Noir barrels of 100% French oak. Flavors of vanilla, spice, and honey complement underlying notes of white grape, pear, orange peel, and clove. Finishes slightly sweet, warming & tannic ~ 10% ABV

Cinnamon Girl

12oz snifter ~ 8; 750ml bottle ~ 23

Bourbon barrel aged imperial milk stout with cinnamon and vanilla ~ 10.6% ABV