Mixed Drinks

Horse Thief Hollow proudly features the finest hand-crafted artisanal and local spirits.

Manchame Margarita


123 Organics Tequila (Tres), housemade roasted jalapeño liqueur, fresh lime and blood oranges with cinnamon simple.

Juniper Jasmine Fizz


Journeyman’s Gin, Jasmine Liqueur, Golden Falernum, fresh lemon and egg white.

HTH Buccaneer


Denizen aged white rum, housemade Creme de Cacao, black lime simple, fresh mandarin and lime.

Sweet & Smokey


Banhez Mezcal, Denizen Dark Rum, Copper & Kings Apple Brandy, Bar Keep Apple Bitters, maple cinnamon simple and fresh lime.

The Rock Star


Zodiac Vodka or Koval Gin, Jasmine Liqueur, simple syrup, fresh lemon and grapes. Topped with Bellafina Prosecco.

Cranberry Smash


Death's Door Gin, fresh cranberries and lime, sage simple and topped with soda.

Blood Moon Rising


Bella Meade Bourbon, House made orange liqueur, black walnut bitters, cinnamon simple, fresh blood oranges and smoked thyme.

Confused Old Fashioned


Few Naval Strength Gin, Papa Pillar Dark Rum, Bittermen's Orange Cream Bitters, pure cane sugar syrmp.

Lizzy's Perfect Manhattan


Journeyman's Rye, Imbue Bittersweet Vermouth, house-made orange liqueur, and black cherry vanilla bourbon bitters.

Specialty Bloody Mary, Maria, Derby and Matilda


Your choice of Prairie Cucumber Vodka, Hank's Vodka, Tequila, Buffalo Trace Bourbon or Death's Door Gin in your bartender’s choice of special Bloodies of the Day! Ask your server or bartender. (Saturday & Sunday only).


Whiskey Flights

Pick three! Flight includes 1 oz tastings.

Rye Me


Buffalo Trace, High West Double Rye, Journeyman's Last Feather Rye, Old Weller Antique Bourbon, 1792 Ridgemont Reserve, Teeling Irish Whiskey, Park Cognac VS

Middle Ground


Eagle Rare Bourbon, Few Bourbon, Few Rye, High West Rendezvous Rye, High West Campfire Rye, Park Cognac VSOP

High Point


Blanton's Bourbon, Breckenridge Bourbon, High West Bourye Park City, Koval Rye, Compass Box The Spice Tree Blended Scotch, Compass Box The Peat Monster Blended Scotch, Park Cognac Borderies

Gin Flight

Pick four!

Flight includes 1 oz tastings


Journeyman's Bilberry Black Hearts Gin, Koval Gin, Koval Barrel Aged Gin, and Few Standard Issue Naval Strength Gin


Michael David Petite Petit

10 glass / 36 bottle

Lodi, California. A blend of 85% Petite Sirah and 15% Petit Verdot, with aromas of dark fruit, vanilla, and cocoa. Rich, jammy, and nicely tannic.

Block Nine Pinot Noir

10 glass / 36 bottle

St. Helena, California. Flavorful and silky in the mouth with good body, this wine is seductive, showing wild cherries and a hint of sandalwood.

Andeluna Cellars Filosur Malbec 2014

9 glass / 32 bottle

Mendoza, Argentina. With a jammy berry nose and floral notes, this medium-bodied malbec pleases.

5 Rows Merlot

9 glass / 34 bottle

Lodi, California. Shows seductive flavors of plums, currants and sweet cherries.

William Hill Cabernet Sauvignon

9 glass / 32 bottle

Napa, California. Aromas and flavors of dark cherry, cassis, ripe plum, and blueberry are complemented by subtle, sweet vanilla notes.

Mouton Noir Horseshoes & Handgrenades

11 glass / 40 bottle

McMinnvile, Oregon and Washington red blend. Think cherry pits and leather whips.

Ryan Patrick Riesling

9 glass / 32 bottle

Columbia Valley, California. Hints of ripe pear, white peach, citrus, and orange blossom with traces of fresh apple and mineral undertones are pleasing on the nose.

La Fiera Pinot Grigio

8 glass / 24 bottle

Veneto, Italy. Light floral and fruity bouquet featuring apples and pears. The palate is bright, fresh and dry, showing nice balance and a lingering acidity that makes it perfect for a variety of lighter cuisine.

Bellafina Prosecco

9 glass / 32 bottle

Veneto, Italy. Intensely aromatic and crisp on the palate, with aromas and flavors of yellow apple, white peach, pear, and notes of white flowers.

Domaine de Pellehaut Rosé

9 glass / 32 bottle

Gascony, France. Salmon pink color, slightly pale. Intense nose, very fragant, characterized by cherry and strawberry and a mix of floral notes.

Dark Horse Chardonnay

8 glass / 28 bottle

Paso Robles, California. Rich flavors of baked apple and pear, layered with toasted oak notes of caramel and brown spice.

Ventana Chardonnay

10 glass / 36 bottle

Monterey, California. Perfectly balanced, with tropical fruit and spicy floral tones, and a hint of Gala apples. Light oak notes lead to hints of vanilla and honey highlights.

Ventana Sauvignon Blanc

10 glass / 36 bottle

Monterey, California. Wonderful flavors of white peach, citrus zest, and floral touches. The wine is completely dry with rich rounded texture and a julep crispness.

Wild Blossom Meadery

Chicago, Illinois. Ask your server or bartender about seasonal meads.


We hand select the finest craft spirits. Taste them for yourself.


Death’s Door Organic Gin

Middleton, Wisconsin

Journeyman's Bilberry Black Hearts Organic Gin

Three Oaks, Michigan

Few Barrel Aged Gin

Evanston, Illinois

Koval Gin

Chicago, Illinois

Few Breakfast Gin

Evanston, Illinois

Few Naval Strength Gin

Evanston, Illinois

Bourbon and Whiskey

Big Ass Bourbon

Bardstown, Kentucky

Breckenridge Bourbon


Buffalo Trace Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Clyde May's Whiskey


Eagle Rare Bourbon


Few Bourbon

Evanston, Illinois

New Holland Beer Barrel Bourbon


Old Weller Antique Bourbon


1792 Ridgemont Reserve Bourbon

Bardstown, Kentucky

Blanton's Bourbon


Koval Rye

Chicago, Illinois

Few Rye

Evanston, Illinois

Angel’s Envy Finished Rye


James E. Pepper "1776" Straight Rye


Templeton Rye


Journeyman's Last Feather Rye

Three Oaks, Michigan


New Holland White Rum


Ballast Point Three Sheets Spiced Rum

San Diego, California


Tito’s Vodka

Austin, Texas

CD Vodka

Midlothian, Illinois. Ask your server about the different flavors from our neighbors over at CD.

Crop Organic Vodka


Crop Organic Meyer Lemon Vodka


Square One Organic Bergamot Vodka



Koval Seasonal Liqueurs

Chicago, Illinois

Copper and Kings Brandy


Copper and Kings Lavender Absinthe





Seattle Cider Dry


Seattle Cider Semi Sweet


Wild Blossom Cyser