Mixed Drinks

Horse Thief Hollow proudly features the finest hand-crafted artisanal and local spirits.

The Rock Star


Your choice of Prairie Vodka or Koval Gin. Koval Jasmine Liqueur, fresh lemons, grapes, and a Bellafina Prosecco float.

Freshy Fresh Paloma


Tequila Cabeza, fresh grapefruit, Pamplemousse Combier Liqueur, soda topper.

Mules Around the World


Your choice of a Chicago Mule (Koval Vodka), Kentucky Mule (Buffalo Trace Bourbon), Irish Mule (Paddy's Irish Whiskey), London Mule (Death's Door Gin), or Mexican Mule (Tequila Cabeza) with fresh lime, and topped with Cock'n Bull ginger beer. Served in a copper mug.

Lizzy's Perfect Manhattan


Journeyman's Rye Whiskey, Imbue Bittersweet Vermouth, house-made orange liqueur, and black cherry vanilla bourbon bitters.

HTH Old Fashioned


Breckenridge Bourbon, orange bitters and Demerara simple syrup. Garnished with fresh orange zest and black cherries.

Seasonal Wild Blossom Mead


Ask your server about the selection available from our local meadery.


Michael David Petite Petit

10 glass / 36 bottle

Lodi, California. A blend of 85% Petite Sirah and 15% Petit Verdot, with aromas of dark fruit, vanilla, and cocoa. Rich, jammy, and nicely tannic.

Block Nine Pinot Noir

9 glass / 34 bottle

St. Helena, California. Flavorful and silky in the mouth with good body, this wine is seductive, showing wild cherries and a hint of sandalwood.

Andeluna Cabernet Sauvignon

10 glass / 36 bottle

Uco Valley, Mendoza, Argentina. Deep red color, spicy aromas with a hint of coffee and mint. Fresh balanced, structured and silky.

Gainey Vineyard Merlot

10 glass / 36 bottle

Santa Ynez County, California. Fragrant black cherry and dark plum aromas mingle with with vanilla, milk chocolate and light herbal scents. Juicy and succulent on the palate, this wine has concentrated dark cherry, plum, and cassis flavors with a tea-left spice finish.

Padrillos Malbec

9 glass / 34 bottle

Mendoza, Argentina. Young profile, with a fresh style and violet floral aromas. Flavors of plum, cherries, dried berries prevail, with a touch of white pepper on the finish.

Matthew Fritz Red Wine Blend

10 glass / 36 bottle

North Coast, California. A juicy, richly textured palate with notes of spice, clove, and licorice. A smooth balance of acid and tannins makes this wine sleek and supple in the mouth.

La Fiera Pinot Grigio

8 glass / 28 bottle

Veneto, Italy. Light floral and fruity bouquet featuring apples and pears. The palate is bright, fresh and dry, showing nice balance and a lingering acidity that makes it perfect for a variety of lighter cuisine.

Ryan Patrick Riesling

9 glass / 32 bottle

Columbia Valley, California. Hints of ripe pear, white peach, citrus, and orange blossom with traces of fresh apple and mineral undertones are pleasing on the nose.

Bellafina Prosecco

9 glass / 32 bottle

Veneto, Italy. Intensely aromatic and crisp on the palate, with aromas and flavors of yellow apple, white peach, pear, and notes of white flowers.

Domaine de Pellehaut Rosé

8 glass / 28 bottle

Gascony, France. Salmon pink color, slightly pale. Intense nose, very fragant, characterized by cherry and strawberry and a mix of floral notes.

Ventana Chardonnay

10 glass / 36 bottle

Monterey, California. Perfectly balanced, with tropical fruit and spicy floral tones, and a hint of Gala apples. Light oak notes lead to hints of vanilla and honey highlights.

Old Coach Road Sauvignon Blanc

9 glass / 34 bottle

Nelson, New Zealand. Wild scents of grapefruit, gooseberry, anise, and white flowers. Finishes with a mouthwatering vibrancy and fine cut acid.


We hand select the finest craft spirits. Taste them for yourself.



Evanston, Illinois


Chicago, Illinois

Prairie Straight

Minneapolis, Minnesota

Gin & Aquavit

Death’s Door Gin

Middleton, Wisconsin

Greenhook Ginsmiths Old Tom Gin

Brooklyn, New York

Koval Gin

Chicago, Illinois


Afro Head

Trinidad, West Indies

Cutwater Three Sheets Spiced

San Diego, California

Denizen White

Trinidad, West Indies

Diplomatico Copper Pot Still (12 yr)

Planas Valley, Venezuela

Shipwreck Spiced

St. Kitts

Trader Vic's Dark

Minneapolis, Minnesota

Tequila & Mezcal

Añejo 123 Organic

Amatitan, Jalisco, Mexico

Tequila Cabeza

Arandas, Jalisco, Mexico

Wahaka Reposado Mezcal

San Dionisio Ocotepec, Oaxaca, Mexico

Scotch & Cognac

Glenrothes Scotch

Rothes, Scotland

Monkey Shoulder Scotch

Dufftown, Banffshire, Scotland

Cognac Park Borderies


Cognac Park VSOP


Brandy & Liqueur

Copper & Kings Butchertown Brandy

Louisville, Kentucky

Koval Ginger Liqueur

Chicago, Illinois

Koval Seasonal Liqueur

Chicago, Illinois

Kringle Cream Liqueur

Middleton, Wisconsin

Millard Fillmore Brandy

Ukiah, California

Bourbon, Rye & Irish Whiskey

1792 Bourbon

Bardstown, Kentucky

Belle Meade Bourbon

Greenbrier, Tennessee

Belle Meade Bourbon Madeira Cask

Greenbrier, Tennessee

Blanton's Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Breckenridge Bourbon

Breckenridge, Colorado

Buffalo Trace Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Eagle Rare Bourbon

Frankfort, Kentucky

Few Bourbon

Evanston, Illinois

Few Rye

Evanston, Illinois

Glendalough Irish Whiskey

Glendalough, Ireland

Journeyman Rye

Three Oaks, Michigan

Koval Bourbon

Chicago, Illinois

Koval Millet

Chicago, Illinois

Koval Oat

Chicago, Illinois

Koval Rye

Chicago, Illinois

Paddy's Irish Whiskey

Cork, Ireland

West Cork Irish Whiskey

West Cork, Ireland

Whistle Pig Rye

Middlebury, Vermont


Seattle Semisweet Cider


6.5 oz tall boy

Seattle Dry Cider


6.5 oz tall boy

Wild Blossom Seasonal Cyser


17 oz bottle